Skip to navigation Skip to main content
The law costs draftsman you can count on…

Mitchell v News Group Newspapers [2013] EWCA Civ 1537

Posted Monday 10th February 2014

In Mitchell the MP’s lawyers did not file their costs budget on time, which is seven days before the relevant hearing. The relevant rule (CPR 3.14) provides that unless the court otherwise orders, any party which fails to file a budget despite being required to do so will be treated as having filed a budget comprising only the applicable court fees. CPR 3.9 gives a party a chance to ask for relief from such sanctions. Mitchell was refused relief from sanctions at first instance and subsequently appealed the decision. The Court of Appeal upheld the Master’s decision and Mitchell’s budget was limited to recovery of court fees only.

In coming to its decision the Court sought to distinguish between trivial non-compliances which might entitle a party to relief, and others where the burden was on the defaulting party, and there had to be good reason for default. And being a bit busy and stretched, as was submitted by Mitchell, did not fall into the “good reason” category.

“The merit of the rule is that it sets out a stark and simple default sanction. The expectation is that the sanction will usually apply unless (i) the breach is trivial or (ii) there is a good reason for it. It is true that the court has the power to grant relief, but the expectation is that, unless (i) or (ii) is satisfied, the two factors mentioned in the rule will usually trump other circumstances. If partial relief were to be encouraged, that would give rise to uncertainty and complexity.”

For full Judgment click on the link below:

http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2013/1537.html

See what our clients have to say…

We have used the services of County Cost Consultants Ltd for a number of years now and their performance and the results they achieve have been consistently excellent and better than all other costs draftsmen or lawyers that we have used previously. They consistently produce excellent bills and achieve very quick and very good results and payments. Alex Clapp, Director, often has personal conduct of negotiating settlements in our cases and this leads to a superb level of recovery for us. We have also always found County Cost’s staff without exception to be extremely competent, thorough and efficient. I would recommend County Cost’s services very highly indeed.
Michael Saul, TJL solicitors
For expert drafting, negotiations and costs advocacy contact us today on 0844 579 6885 or send us your details and we’ll contact you within 24hrs…
If you have an urgent enquiry please contact us on 0844 579 6885 our expert team will be available to help.